The following article, exploring offshore wind subsea power cables, has been republished with the kind permission from the authors: Othmane El Mountassir & Charlotte Strang-Moran from ORE Catapult | Published September 2018 | AP-0018
Installation, Operation & Trends
By the end of 2018, installed offshore windpower capacity will reach a total of 30.2GW, with 22.9GW of generation in Europe and 7.3GW across the rest of the world. The UK remains the global leader in offshore wind, with a total capacity of 6,385MW and an additional capacity of 3.2GW entering operation by 2020. As the industry’s generation capacity continues to grow, so does the need for developing reliable, high-capacity transmission cable technologies.
Subsea power cable failure is frequently reported as an issue for offshore wind farm operators. Such failures are reported to account for 75-80% of the total cost of offshore wind insurance claims – in comparison, cabling makes up only around 9% of the overall cost of an offshore wind farm. A lack of available data on cable failures led ORE Catapult to develop an interactive tool for internal use, which captures information about UK offshore wind projects and their power cables’ lifecycle from the installation to the operational phase.
This paper summarises some of the most pertinent insights on cable failures gleaned from the Catapult’s use of the tool and sets forth suggestions on how to improve knowledge-sharing in the offshore wind community to reduce the impact of future failures.
Headlines
The UK’s operational offshore wind farms are using 62 export cables totalling a length of 1,499km and over 1,806km of inter-array cables to transport the 6,385MW of electrical generation.
A total of 43 array and export cable failures have been reported since 2007. Issues associated with manufacturing and/or installation are reported to be the most common cause of cable failure.
From 2014 to the end of 2017, recorded cable failures at UK offshore wind projects have led to a cumulative loss of power generation of approximately 1.97TWh.
UK Offshore Wind Trends
The UK generates more electricity from offshore wind than any other country in the world. Operational offshore wind farms are currently generating 6,738MW using 1717 turbines.
In 2017, the UK installed 1681MW, representing more than half of the new offshore wind power capacity built in Europe. It is forecasted that by 2020, there will be a record-breaking year for new capacity – largely driven by delayed wind farms and the deployment of large-capacity turbines in the 7MW 8MW range. The following figures provide an insight into current UK offshore wind sector trends.
Wind Development: By the end of 2018, installed offshore wind power capacity will reach a total of 30.2GW worldwide, with 22.9GW of generation in Europe and 7.3 GW in rest of the world. The UK remains the European country with the largest installed capacity, reaching a total capacity of 7,851 MW by the end of 2018.
Farm Capacity: By categorising wind farms into three ranges of generation capacity, it can be seen that the larger the capacity range of the wind farms, the higher the number of wind turbines being used. It is expected that this trend will change with the deployment of higher-capacity turbines, reducing the number required.
Progressive Trends: Since the development of the first demonstrator projects in 2003, the UK’s offshore wind sector has witnessed strong growth, supported by government incentives and investor confidence in the sector. This can be demonstrated in the figure above, where we can see over the years an increase in the number of offshore wind farms and demonstrators with different generation capacities.
Distance from Shore:The UK’s geographic location makes it ideal for offshore wind generation. Early developments from the Round 1 and Round 2 leasing phases were relatively small and close to shore. In contrast, recent projects and future developments have seen and will see this distance increase to the 50-90km range from shore to take advantage of the wind strength in these areas.
Subsea Cable Trends
The rapid growth of the offshore wind sector has led to the development of a number of new subsea cable technologies. This was mainly supported by a robust cable-related supply chain with leading organisations in manufacturing, services and academia present across the UK. The demand for subsea power cables will continue to grow at a fast pace to support both future offshore wind development and the subsea power interconnector sector.
Export Cables are vital for transmission of the generated power to the grid. The UK’s operational offshore wind farms are using 62 export cables totalling a length of 1,499km. The voltage levels of these cables range from 33kV for nearshore wind farms without offshore substations, and up to 132kV, 150kV and 220kV for further-offshore sites with one or two substations.
Export Cable Trends: Research and development activity has led to the development of new cable technologies. Since 2013, over 80% of projects in Europe have deployed export cables with a voltage greater than 150kV. Reflecting the rapid development of cable technologies, 80% of projects commissioned in 2018 will be using cables with a voltage level greater than 200kV.
Array Cable Development:There are over 1,806km of inter-array cables in UK waters. To maximise generation revenue and achieve Levelised Cost of Energy reductions, offshore wind projects will continue to increase in size.
As such, the lengths of array cabling used is expected to increase due to the increased number of turbines and the distance between them.
Array Cable Manufacturers:The cable market is generally global in nature and there are a number of suppliers available. A notable UK success has been achieved with JDR cables, which has supplied numerous UK offshore wind projects, as well as several overseas projects. The expansion of the market and growth of an indigenous UK supply chain is expected to help reduce costs.
Cable Failure Trends
According to industry data obtained by the Catapult, cables account for the largest number of insurance claims in the offshore wind sector. Though subsea cable failures are reported often, publicly-available information remains scarce. The following figures, gleaned from the Catapult’s internal cable database, provide an insight into reported subsea power cable failures in the UK’s offshore wind sector.
Cable Failure: Incidents relating to the installation and operation of subsea power cables are found to be the most costly cause of financial losses in offshore wind industry. Since 2007, 43 known failures of wind farm array and export cables were reported. The issues associated with these failures vary in nature.
Causes of Failure: Issues associated with the manufacturing and/or installation phase are reported to be the most common cause of cable failure. The failure events reported include cases where unplanned faults have occurred, or when planned, pre-emptive repairs have been required to avoid the likelihood of fault.
Fibre Optic and Electrical Faults: In the UK’s offshore wind sector, recorded faults of electrical origin were found to be higher than fibre optics failures. To date, power losses due to fibre optics failure reached an estimated value of 600GWh, while losses due to electrical faults were estimated at 1,160GWh. It should be noted that electrical failures may sometimes lead to the failure of fibre optics.
Costs of Failure: The cost of a cable failure can be considerable, taking into account repair costs and generation revenue loss. From 2014 until the end of 2017, recorded cable failures at UK projects have led to a cumulative generation loss of approx. 1.97TWh, equating to approx. £227M*. This figure demonstrates beyond doubt that the sector is still in need of innovative cable installation and repair technologies. *Based on a strike price of £115/MWh.
Discussion and Next Steps
The UK has a robust subsea cable-related supply chain, encompassing manufacturing, service providers and academia. However, there is still a lack of communication between stakeholder groups. For example, the standardisation of cable installation practices may lead to fewer installation issues, while the dissemination of learned experiences can be used to predict or avoid certain failures and also bridge innovation gaps in manufacturing. However, this is only possible if the parties involved are willing to share the required records. There is a consensus from market stakeholders that subsea cable project activities are currently dispersed, and a more structured and co-ordinated process is required to pull promising technology and ideas through development and demonstration. However, proposed concepts aimed at developing a subsea cable database, which informs and enables stakeholders to identify and bridge gaps in innovation – has been met with scepticism from a number of systems owners and operators; questions remain over whether a live, regularly-updated database would be providing ongoing value and longevity.
To ensure the successful development and implementation of appropriate technologies and processes aimed at reducing cable failures within the offshore wind industry, ORE Catapult is acting as a driver for a number of initiatives such as the Offshore Wind Innovation Hub, subsea cable innovation challenges, and technology demonstration opportunities for SMEs at its Levenmouth Demonstration Turbine. The Catapult also anticipates launching a publicly-available web-based platform dedicated to subsea power cables. To help solve some of the challenges around offshore wind subsea cable applications, ORE Catapult has developed a dedicated internal database and an Offshore Wind Innovation Hub strategic programme dedicated to subsea power cables and future systems. The aim of the internal cable database platform is to provide quantitative information and evidence to support building a consensus to solve common cable issues, while the Offshore Wind Innovation Hub was established to co-ordinate the sector’s innovation needs and provide a comprehensive view of the research funding opportunities available.
It is beyond question that the offshore wind sector will continue to expand further over the coming decades. Future wind farms will make use of higher-capacity turbines and will be located further offshore: with that comes the requirement for robust cable technologies and safe installation and operational practices. The sector must learn from the wider industry and share information and lessons learned so that costs can continue to fall, helping the wider offshore wind supply chain continue its trajectory of growth.
Thorne & Derrick are Specialist Distributors to the UK and international Offshore Wind & Renewable industry to provide safe and reliable LV HV Electrical Cable & Power Distribution Systems up to 66kV – we are highly customer responsive and absolutely committed to providing a world-class service.
Contact our UK Power Team for competitive quotations, fast delivery from stock and technical support or training on all LV-HV products.
NEW Ripley Stripping Tools Improve Safety And Reliability
IMPROVE SAFETY AND RELIABILITY
Cable Stripping Tools
The following blog has been republished alongside the below video from Utility Service Agency, where they demo their favourite Utility Tool® tools for improving safety and reliability during cable preparation.
“What I like about this tool is that it’s very easy to see your blade when you’re doing your chamfer in the field.”
Improve reliability and safety at the same time; take the knife out of your hand and put the Ripley Tools in your hand.
Utility Tool from Ripley offer two by two and four by four cable strippers with bushings. The bushings on each side are specifically designed for the conductor sizes you need. “Take about a twelve to 14 inch cut of all those sizes, and send them off to Ripley tools to get your specifically sized bushing.”
“To use these tools, just run it down to your spot, I have my hand as a stopper. Perfect cut. No scoring. Safe. Good to go.”
For those that need more adjustability on the system, the WS 71 and WS 72 Series provides mid span. Just tighten it down and again, run it right down. If you want to take the WS 71 and 72 and make them into one tool, take the US07-7000.
This is new tool from Ripley is capable of doing end strips and also your midspan strips all in one tool. “We used to have two tools for your chamfering. Now we have one tool.”
We also have a US10 7000 which performs a 30 degree chamfer, and then we have a US10 7001 which performs a 45 degree chamfer. See below for further product specification.
US07 Series
Adjustable 600-1000V Secondary Cable Stripper
Introducing the new US07 Adjustable Cable Stripper that quickly and easily end strips or midspan strips cable insulation with no conductor damage on 8 to 1000 kcmil secondary cables. The tool utilizes a size adjustment clamping system to swiftly adjust and lock onto the insulation. Its compact, low friction, thermoplastic, impact-resistant polymer v-jaw and body provides a stable and precise clamping platform in any space.
Equipped with safe, recessed blade to prevent potential injury & blade damage
Quickly adjusts to suit THHN, XHHW & USE secondary cables with 0.3″ to 1.375″ (7.6 mm to 35 mm) cable diameters, eliminating the need for bushings
Easily adjusts with detent actuated knob & fine adjustment knob to match insulation thickness for fast stripping without conductor damage
Features a replaceable, machined & ground tool steel blade
Combines the end & mid-span strip performance of the UtilityTool® WS 71 & WS 72 with added features, stability & cable sizes
Durable bronze bushings provides longevity
US10 Series
URD Cable Insulation Chamfering Tool
The new innovative US10 Cable Insulation Chamfering Tool utilizes a size adjustment clamping system to quickly and easily adjust and lock onto the insulation. Its compact, low friction, thermoplastic V-jaw construction and PTFE-coated aluminium frame provides a stable and precise clamping platform in any space.
Easily adjusts to suit XLPE & EPR insulation materials on 0.5″ to 2.36″ (12.7 mm to 60 mm) cable diameters
30 degree or 45 degree angle bevel models perform with a factory-set chamfer depth of 0.075″ (1.905 mm), adjustable from 0″ to 0.150″ (0 mm to 3.81 mm); 15-35 kV
Equipped with safe, recessed blade to prevent potential injury & blade damage
Features a replaceable, machined & ground tool steel blade
See our complete range of Jointing Tools for the preparation and stripping of LV MV HV cable prior to the installation of joints, terminations and connectors.
Thorne & Derrick International are specialist distributors of LV, MV & HV Cable Installation, Jointing, Duct Sealing, Substation & Electrical Equipment – servicing UK and global businesses involved in cable installations, cable jointing, substation, overhead line and electrical construction at LV, 11kV, 33kV and EHV.
Stephen Harrison – Training & Technical Manager at Current Training Service Pty Ltd
In Part 1 and 2 of the series we discussed how to correctly seal cable ends and explored the different types of cable end caps which have been designed for pulling cables and storage.
Part 3 will explain about water getting into cables when storing cable drums outside.
When cable drums are stored outdoors with end caps attached, the sun and other elements may cause the end cap to move and break the glue seals allowing moisture to migrate into the cable. If this happens, the cables are now in a poor state for installation as there may be some traces water in the cables prior to installation.
This is not an ideal situation.
The use of black sealant mastic and end caps will ensure the seal will not move or crack and water is less likely to penetrate the cables.
It’s important for your cables, which are being stored, to have the best chance of being in a pristine condition when you need to pull them in.
There are many “backyard” ways of sealing cables: PVC insulation tape wrapped around the ends of the cable, cloth and tape wrapped around the ends, plastic bags with tape wrapped around, and sometimes no end caps at all. The best way of sealing cables is with heat shrink or cold apply end caps and mastic.
To recap from Parts 1 & 2, when pulling cables and leaving the cables in pits etc, consider using triple end seals for added protection. When storing cable drums outdoors, consider using a drum storage for extra sealing and storage.
uploaded by Chris Dodds - Thorne & Derrick Sales + Marketing Manager
The European Arc Flash Guide
By MIKE FRAIN CEng FIET MCMI
This publication is a must-read book which provides a practical approach to the management of arc flash risk in electrical power systems for designers, duty holders, consultants, service providers and health and safety specialists.
An arc flash can cause minor injuries, third degree burns and potential death as well as other injuries including blindness, hearing loss, nerve damage and cardiac arrest.
Purchase your copy today by clicking the BUY NOW on the image below.
Overview
This book is essential reading for anyone responsible for designing or putting workers to task on, or near, large power electrical systems. This is especially relevant where local health and safety law uses a risk-based approach to electrical safety such as in Europe.
It is based upon a bedrock of risk management methodology using the 4Ps of Predict, Prevent, Process & Protect to ensure that arc flash hazards are systematically identified, analysed, and prevented from causing harm.
Each of the 4Ps are described in detail starting with a quantitative prediction of harm from the arc flash hazard and then a separate chapter on prevention based upon practical measures to avoid or minimise harm set against a hierarchy of risk control measures.
The chapter on process, policy and procedures gives advice on a methodical approach to creating rules and ensuring competence. Finally, the chapter on protection describes, as a last resort, how personal protective equipment can be selected, used, and maintained.
This book is packed with the fruits of the author’s vast experience and there is a chapter dedicated to myths and mysteries as well as separate chapters for electrical utilities, duty holders, service providers, contractors, legislation, and data collection.
Whilst the book gives you the how to manage arc flash risk, the online European Arc Guide gives you the tools to carry it out. It’s accessible from phones, tablets, and laptops which provides the tools and together with the book is a practical and valuable resource to discover and manage dangerous levels of electrical incident energy in the workplace. Click the link here – www.ea-guide.com
About The Author Mike Frain
Mike Frain is an expert for the BSI live working technical committee TC78, Convenor for the IEC arc flash working group, Project Team Leader for the IEC arc flash guidance for end users project team, vice chair of the IET Engineering Safety Policy Panel and heads up the IET arc flash working group. He has extensive experience delivering electrical safety consultancy and arc flash system studies throughout Europe and beyond for large blue-chip organisations.
MIKE FRAIN CEng FIET MCMI
IEC Convenor for the Arc Flash Working Group
IEC Team Leader for PT 902 Arc Flash Guidance
BSI Expert for Technical Committee 78 Live Working
IET Vice Chair of the Engineering Safety Policy Panel
ARC FLASH CLOTHING
Stockists & Suppliers
ProGARM is a specialist UK Arc Flash Garment and Accessories manufacturer, delivering the ultimate in arc flash protective clothing without compromising on comfort – Thorne & Derrick provide competitive prices and fast delivery for the complete range of ProGarm arc flash clothing designed to protect people and save lives. ProGarm offer a wide range of mens and womens arc flash garments providing comfortable protection to our clients in the LV HV Electrical Power & Substation sectors of the onshore and offshore renewable, rail, utility, data-centre and energy storage sectors.
Techlube is a range of water-based underground Power & Communication cable pulling lubricants designed to provide superior friction reduction and reduce the risk ofcable damage during cable installation, which is the primary cause of 90% of cable damage.
All Techlube cable lubricants share similar chemistries and characteristics:
‘Cling & String’ consistency of Techlube ensures strong adhesion to the duct wall/ cable
Perfect adhesion to cable in wet weather
Resistance to wash off, allowing lubrication even in flooded ducts
Slow drying, leaving a thin film which keeps its lubricating potential assisting with cable pulls to the same duct, preventing ‘cementing’ of the cable
Substantially biodegradable* & non-flammable
Water polymer lubricants with low conductivity
Cable Lubricants By Socomore
Cable Pulling Lubricant Product Benefits
Reduced friction & risk of damage
Compatible with cable jackets & jointing accessories
Regular pulling tension
Temperature stability
Retains lubricating potential
Improved efficiency
Environmentally responsible
Several formulations available
Friction Reduction
The ability to reduce friction between the cable jacket and the conduit provides the means to evaluate performance of cable lubricants.
Friction Theory:
The coefficient of friction, µ is a dimensionless value that is a proportionality constant between the frictional force, F, and the normal force, N. µ=F/N µs : the static coefficient of friction, is defined as the minimal force required to start an object in motion divided by the normal force. µk:the kinetic coefficient of friction, is defined as the minimal force required to keep an object in motion divided by the normal force.
Note: laboratory measured coefficients may not be accurate when used to predict actual cable pulling tensions.
Compatibility
Techlube does not contain any salt, detergent, paraffin or grease which can degrade cable jackets or cause hot spots, and has passed compatibility testing with materials commonly used in power cable accessories, joints & cable jackets including HDPE, LLDPE, Natural Rubber, CPE, CSPE, EPR, XLPE, PVC and Neoprene.
Cable Pulling Lubricants Techlube Range
Techlube Range
Cable Lubricant Description
Viscosity (cPs)
Uses
HD
Heavy duty cable lubricant for heavy cables & difficult cable pulls
Pourable lubricant for lighter cable installations
2000-3500
MULTI
Multi-purpose cable lubricant
5400-7400
FO
Fibre optic & sub duct installation lubricant with high elasticity for reduced consumption
2000-3500
M
Cable lubricant with microspheres, specially designed for Telecom industry
1800-2800
*Excluding microspheres in Techlube M
Directions For Use
Techlube products are easy to apply through a variety of methods:
Hand
Manual Pouring
Pumping
Cone Feeder Systems
Recommended Cable Pulling Lubricant Quantity
These quantities are given for reference and guidance only. Every installation is different depending on complexity, route, cable and duct variables.
For plastic conduit (PVC, Polyethylene) use the following equation: Q = 0.0064 x L x D (HD, PHD, MULTI) Q = 0.0080 x L x D (FO) Q = 0.0004 x L x D (M)
For multiple concrete, clay tile, fibre cement, fibre filled & wooden conduit use the following equation: Q = 0.0098 x L x D (HD, PHD, MULTI) Q = 0.0120 x L x D (FO) Q= 0.0006 x L x D (M)
Q= Quantity of Techlube L = The total length of the pull in meters D = The inside diameter of the conduit in centimeters
Physical Properties
Appearance: Viscous liquid
VOC: 0% or O g/1
PH: >=5.0 – <8.0
Store tightly sealed in adequately ventilated premises. Shelf life is one year from the manufacturing date.
General Requirements for Cable Lubricants
Cable & Duct Compatibility: prolonged exposure to the lubricant should not adversely affect the cable or duct performance for the life of the cable
Friction Reduction:the initial installation should not expose the cable to excessive pulling forces or generate damaging heating effects and when completely dried, the lubricant should not ‘cement’ the cable in place
Environmental Safety: the chemical consistency of the lubricant should not adversely affect the users or environment into which it is placed
Fire Resistance: the lubricant deposits should not continually burn or spread a flame along the length of the duct/ cable
Electrical Considerations: the lubricant should not affect the volume resistivity of the semi-conducting cable jacket when used in conjunction with power cables
The below video shows the Socomore Techlube HD heavy duty water-based cable pulling lubricant in use. Suitable for underground cable installations and is designed for heavy power and difficult cable routes and pulls (LV HV).
Cable lubricants manufactured by Socomore are recommended when installing LV-HV power, fibre optic and telecoms cables into cable duct.
CABLE PULLING & CLEANING PRODUCTS
Thorne & Derrick International are the UK’s leading stockist and supplier of Cable Pulling & Cable Laying Equipment for the installation of underground land and subsea power cables and overhead lines up to 400kV – the products support cable pulling teams to install LV MV HV cables into trench, cable duct, risers and all forms of cable containment.
Compound Box Filling Compound end boxes rarely get attention — until one fails. Across ageing networks, replacement of compound-filled end boxes is becoming more frequent, particularly where original insulation systems have deteriorated and air insulation is not practical because...
Nexans 240–300mm² Multi-Joint – Medium Voltage Cable Joint Installation Medium voltage cable jointing requires reliability, consistency and safe installation practices. The Nexans 240–300mm² Multi-Joint is designed to simplify medium voltage jointing while maintaining high electrical performance for demanding power...